There is an uproar going on amongst RWA members.
I probably wouldn’t have paid much attention to what is happening with RWA’s Rita contest for published authors if I wasn’t the contest diva that I am. I knew BookStrand was a small publisher, but because my stories will be released in print, I assumed that they would be eligible for Rita should I choose to enter them. I recently discovered I was wrong.
It seems that the RWA has decided that to be considered eligible for Rita, an author’s book must now be “mass” published. That immediately cuts out every author who has books that are print-on-demand. Like mine. The irony is that I am also not eligible for the unpublished Golden Heart contest. So am I published or not? It’s not like you can be a “little bit” published. In my mind, it’s like being a “little bit” pregnant. Either you are or you aren’t.
While I normally don’t get involved in RWA politics, this bothered me enough I wanted to talk about my feelings. RWA has in essence told me that my membership doesn’t matter to them. Oh, wait. It does value my membership because they need help judging the Golden Heart — just not participating in it.
Is it because the RWA doesn’t consider small pubbed authors “worthy”? I believe there’s an underlying prejudice that unless an author is published by a big New York house, her work isn’t very good. Perhaps that was the case in the past. Small pubs and epublishers sometimes received little or no editing before being placed for sale. I can assure you, that is not the case now. A story has to be of high quality to sell. So what exactly is the RWA afraid of? My guess is that if one of the epubbed authors actually won the Rita, it would shatter the glass ceiling that keeps authors from big publishers on a different echelon than the rest of the membership. Harsh, yes. But after attending a couple of RWA national conferences, I am of the opinion that there are some PAN authors (some, not all by any means) who believe they are… better than the rest of the crowd.
Okay, I’ll step off my soapbox. This has just been bothering me because I hate feeling so… impotent. I also hate paying dues to a group that only values what I can bring to them and offers nothing in return. I will stay a member of RWA, but only because I adore my local chapter and couldn’t continue to write without their support.
But the epubbed author in me is highly offended.

